I guess a disclaimer should be offered up-front: I’m a total Apple fangirl. I’m typing up this blog on a MacBook Pro, I own an iPhone. And while I’m not the only one by any means, I am really and seriously in love with my latest Apple toy.

I bought an iPad 2. I named it Mnemosyne, after the Greek personification of memory and the mother of the Muses. While my laptop is called the “Turing Machine” after one of the fathers of modern computing, all my Apple peripherals are named after Greek mythological figures: my iPod was Apollo, who was the god of music as well as the sun; and my iPhone is Hermes, as it delivers text messages to me regularly.
The purchase was ostensibly for class, to load up readings to carry to class that would be lighter, more convenient, and possibly more eco-friendly* than printing everything out (one of my classes had decided to forego textbooks in favor of a tangled web of PDF files). I did download some helpful academic programs (GoodReader deserves all the praise that it gets), but I also decided to go to the local FedEx Office to print out double-sided copies of my readings for class anyways, so my excuse pretty quickly flew out the window.
What can I say? I just focus better when I read stuff on paper for class. Also, as much as I love my toys, sometimes my eyes need a break from digital screens.
*I’m still not sure if e-books and such readers for them like the Kindle/Nook/iPad are actually more eco-friendly than good ol’ paper, and neither, it seems, are other people.
I also, however, was quick to download games and other entertainment: both Marvel and DC offer applications to download digital comics (and have helpful links to purchase paper editions as well), and there are a lot of gaming options, including new-for-the-iPad advancements/adaptations (such as a new version of Dead Space by EA) and some great board game adaptations (from classics like Monopoly and Scrabble to still-favorites-but-lesser-known gems like Catan and Carcassonne).
Bypassing all the pre-loaded iPad apps for now (things that Mac users will be used to, like Calendar, Notes, YouTube, and Photo Booth), here is a screenshot of my second screen page, with third-party apps gloriously displayed:

The Video folder includes Hulu and Netflix, as I have accounts for both. Here’s an expanded view of my Games folder:

Fun Mac Tip: Holding down the home button at the bottom center of the iPad (or iPhone) and clicking the top power button will take a screenshot of the device.
I’m not going to do a run-through of each and every app, but I did want to cover my favorites pretty quickly:
- Battleheart is a really fun little hack-and-slash game with an amazingly adorable cast of characters. It has a really simple control system, where you drag a character to an enemy to attack, or to another character to use a special ability. You can switch up your team, recruit new members, buy equipment, and play in arenas until your adorable characters are swarmed by equally adorable goblins and bats. Very simplistic but very addicting.
- Dropbox is a must-have. An account up to 2GB is free, and I use it to sync documents between my MacBook Pro, iPhone, and iPad, as well as back up important papers and such until I’ve turned them in.
- GoodReader is amazing. You can read lovely PDF files, mark them up with highlighting and notes (and save these changes to a second copy, so your original stays pristine), and everything comes through in bright, crisp color – I scoff at your Kindle or black & white Nook.
- Instapaper makes reading long articles and such a pleasure. You sign up for a free account, add a little bookmarklet to your bookmarks bar, and save all the reading you don’t want to finish at the moment to your account. Sync it up while you’re on wifi and a simplistic text-and-pictures version is available offline for you to read at your leisure. They also offer editor-picked choices of popular articles, if you’re not sure what you want to read on your commute.
- The New Yorker has a really beautiful iPad app. As a print subscriber, you have access to the digital editions as well. The iPad makes reading magazines a really pleasurable experience, with easy scrolling and links to additional material that a print magazine could never offer: slideshows of additional images, audio clips of poets reading their work, etc. (A one-year print and digital subscription is $69.99, only $10 more than the one-year digital-only subscription at $59.99 – monthly digital subscripts are available for $5.99, and individual issues for $4.99.)
Moving beyond apps and into a general review, the iPad is a genius device. It’s beautifully designed, which is only to be expected for an Apple product. It also just feels nice in your hands: I have a slip case for protection (see below) when I put it in my bag, but I don’t use any permanent case for the front or back. It just feels too glossy between my fingers for me to want to put a case on it.

It’s great for curling up in bed and watching video – it’s very light and comfortable to use, more so than a laptop. The iPad 2 clocks in around 1.35 lbs. The MacBook Pro at 5.6 lbs. Also, the slide button on the top of the right side of the iPad, where the silent/vibrate button is on an iPhone, can be set to either mute/unmute or can be used to lock or unlock the screen rotation – so you can set a video on landscape mode, lock the orientation, and then curl up on the bed in whatever position you want without having the screen get all twisty on you. Which is nice, cause I’m the kind of person that likes to watch video while curled up on my side. Which is awkward, to say the least, with a laptop (damn hinged screen), and just so much cozier with the iPad.
The iPad is also a great little e-reader device. Kindle offers an iPad app, so you have full access to anything from the Kindle store. Apple also has its own app, iBooks, with an integrated bookstore, and a slick digital-bookshelf display:

I’ll be honest: I still love my physical, paper-pages books. They’re heavy, they collect dust, they take up copious amounts of space on shelves. But there’s just something about physical books and turning pages that I’m in love with. Still, I have the iBooks program, and I did download the first book in the Mistborn series by Brandon Sanderson, which my friend Mark has been pestering me to read for over a year now. It was only $1.99, which was pretty awesome, and it did allow me to read in the car when my mom and I left at 5:30 AM to get to LA in time for another of my grad school orientations. It was way too dark out still to have been reading a paperback. Sure, you can buy book lights and stuff, but it was nice and convenient. And just like any other e-reader, you can carry hundreds of books at once for only 1.35 lbs.
For my fellow geeks, I would definitely recommend an iPad (or Nook color) over something black and white, like the Kindle. Why? Because a full-color screen means full-color comics: as previously stated, Marvel and DC both offer apps for the iPad, where you can download both free and paid comics. With DC having just rebooted their universe, it’s a great and far more approachable time to start getting into comics, instead of getting scared by the really high issue numbers and being concerned about massive amounts of backstory.
Also, if you were inclined to scan high-resolution copies of your legally purchased comic books (because you would never illegally download them from the internet), they would not show up well on a Kindle. On a beautifully colored iPad screen, however, comics are a joy to read. Occasionally, there are some issues with double-page spreads, but it’s still a very enjoyable experience.
So, would I recommend that you run out and buy an iPad? I guess that depends on what you want to do.
I tend to agree with the viewpoint that the iPad is a great tool for absorbing media – The New Yorker app is one excellent example of such. Watching video, reading articles, and playing games are all fantastic. However, I can’t really picture using it to heavily produce media.* The on-screen keyboard is definitely easier to use than the tiny one on the iPhone, but it still isn’t the best experience, especially for those used to touch-typing on a full keyboard. (For instance, ‘apostrophes’ and “quotation marks” aren’t available on the primary screen, which makes typing out more than a few contractions or lines of dialogue irritating. The purchase of a wireless keyboard (yay for Bluetooth!) might make a difference in this, and Apple actually offers a version of their wireless keyboard with an iPad dock integrated. This, however, raises the point that you’d might as well get a laptop instead if you intend to be carrying around a keyboard frequently. Part of the appeal of the iPad is the portability and sleek design.
(Then again, the most expensive version of the iPad (WiFi + 3G and 64 GB) will currently run you $829. Even with the addition of the $69.99 Apple keyboard, it remains cheaper than even the lowest-priced MacBook Air ($999) or MacBook Pro ($1199), as far as other portable Apple options go.)
*I haven’t yet tried out the iPad versions of the popular Mac apps iMovie and GarageBand yet. (If my friends and I get around to the collaborative vlog we talked about during the summer, I might pick up iMovie and toy around with it.) I’ve heard good things about both, but neither are currently programs that I would have use for. Also, for heavy creative purposes, I still imagine that their Mac computer counterparts would be more useful.

Sure, there are a lot of competitors out there – Lenovo, Samsung, Toshiba and more offer versions of tablets. Still, the iPad continues to dominate the market, and I can’t imagine that changing in the next few years, unless something truly revolutionary comes out. (Remember all those so-called “iPhone killers”?) And with their huge share of the market, App availability is something to take into consideration. Developers build for the iPad. Sure, there are a lot of lame things cluttering up the iTunes App Store, but there are a lot of really great programs, too. And while there are some Android-only apps, there continue to be many more that are iPhone/iPad exclusive – and developers often develop Apple versions of apps first, as there’s a bigger market there.
Finally, I have no idea what syncing to a Windows computer* is like, as I use a Mac laptop. I do know that with a MacBook Pro, iPhone, and iPad, all my toys play together nicely on the same WiFi network, and as far as syncing documents back and forth with programs like Dropbox, that work on all platforms. I have a fair number of apps that are accessible on both my phone and the iPad, which is great. And there are often Mac version of apps for your laptop or desktop Apple computer that will sync or share with portable versions (such as the iWork suite of Pages, Keynote, and Numbers; iHomework; Bento; and many others).
*Apparently, when iOS 5 is released this fall, needing a computer at all to sync will be unnecessary – something you might want to take into consideration if you’ve been hesitant about mixing Windows and Mac products.
So: should you shell out the money for an iPad? If you can afford it, if you love Apple products, if you already own other Apple products – I would say absolutely. While I definitely purchased some new apps the day I got my iPad, I had many I’d already downloaded for the phone that were cross-compatible, which was nice.
If you’re hesitant but you think you want one, head down to your local Apple store (or Best Buy, or whatever other authorized dealer is around) and play with one in-store. I have a feeling that you’ll fall in love just like I did. The Walnut Creek, CA Apple store had a bunch of apps pre-loaded that let you feel out the capabilities of the device. If you’re looking for a more data-entry heavy machine (like for taking notes every day in class) that is still less than a full computer/laptop, it’s possible a netbook would be more your style. Or you might want to try out the iPad/wireless keyboard route.
If you’re an anti-Mac person – well, sorry for the last 2000 or so words, and I doubt I’ll be able to change your mind. Mac haters are just as enthusiast as Mac lovers. (I should know – I used to be a Windows girl, and groaned whenever I had to use a Mac for class.) But you should still head down and play with one. I went through an enlightenment, and maybe you will, too!
Edit (25 September 2011 @ 7:04 PM): Take a look at this clip from McSweeney’s FAQ about their iPhone/iPad app for what I mean about Apple’s majority market share:
Q. Why is there no version for Android?
A. Unfortunately, we have no plans to make an Android version of the app at the moment. Apps written for the iOS and Android operating systems cannot quickly be ported to one another — they have to be re-written from scratch. Developing an app takes a long time and because we are a small company, with an even smaller technical department, we just do not have the resources to support multiple platforms. There is no subterfuge, corporate bias or underhand dealings — Apple’s platform was simply the most mature when we first decided to make an app. We would love to have an Android version, but we’re just too busy right now. Sorry.